![]() |
What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Printable Version +- Bring4th (https://www.bring4th.org/forums) +-- Forum: Bring4th Studies (https://www.bring4th.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: Spiritual Development & Metaphysical Matters (https://www.bring4th.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=9) +--- Thread: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? (/showthread.php?tid=19092) |
RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 11:52 AM)Great Central Sun Wrote:(04-14-2021, 02:16 PM)zedro Wrote:(04-14-2021, 12:01 PM)Patrick Wrote: My parents always used that saying in order to say that you can't just say you're going to do good, you also have to do it. So "intentions aren't good enough, there must also be action". No because action causes consequence on the other, hence karma, which is external. Intent is polarity, which is internal and only affects the self. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - AnthroHeart - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 11:55 AM)zedro Wrote:(04-15-2021, 11:52 AM)Great Central Sun Wrote:(04-14-2021, 02:16 PM)zedro Wrote:(04-14-2021, 12:01 PM)Patrick Wrote: My parents always used that saying in order to say that you can't just say you're going to do good, you also have to do it. So "intentions aren't good enough, there must also be action". Interesting. So how do the negatives here on Earth not have to face their karma for millennia? RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 11:57 AM)Great Central Sun Wrote: Interesting. So how do the negatives here on Earth not have to face their karma for millennia? Karma is basically a negotiation between otherselves to balance experience/the logos. Creating catalyst for each other is part of the evolutionary requirement. Karma isn't about punishing bad behavior, it's not about morals/ethics, or payback/consequence, it's simply an agreed upon balancing of experiences. Karma is like a type of force. So everyone faces karma, it just not be what you expect it to be. Ra pointed this out, that determining what the exact karmic effects would be is impossible to determine. It can only be truly evaluated in hindsight in the final merging of all selves (end of the octave). So karma doesn't equal 'bad', it's just a connection created between another entity to be resolved/balanced, instantly or in time, in the original relationship or through successive experiences with others. For instance, me writing to you has a function of my polarity (service), it is my intent. If you never read it, well nothing happens karmically, no experience on your side was generated. Once you read it however, a karmic link is established as it now affects your experience. Now there may be an instantaneous dissolution of that karma if the effect on you is minimal, but if I catalyze you in some way (affect your evolution), we can get karmically entangled, and we may not be aware. While that doesn't mean we owe each other anything and may have no further engagement in this life or others, it may mean that we need further lessons elsewhere to understand how we created that entanglement in the first place, to understand our function in the creation itself. So if I wrote something that triggered you in a less than optimal way, I may need further lessons from interactions with others to optimize that aspect of myself (my karma). Conversely you may need further experience to balance yourself to optimize your learning (your karma). Trying to balance those karmic systems with further experience will generate other karmic systems, keeping that wheel turning until that evolution is resolved. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 11:52 AM)Great Central Sun Wrote:(04-14-2021, 02:16 PM)zedro Wrote:(04-14-2021, 12:01 PM)Patrick Wrote: My parents always used that saying in order to say that you can't just say you're going to do good, you also have to do it. So "intentions aren't good enough, there must also be action". It's not the intent alone. Karma requires the action, BUT the karma resulting from an action is supremely affected by the intent behind the action. Karma is not a stupid calculation only based on actions. It is an exquisitely precise calculation where your intent has a very heavy weight. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 12:33 PM)Patrick Wrote: It's not the intent alone. Karma requires the action, BUT the karma resulting from an action is supremely affected by the intent behind the action. Of course, intent/polarity is the potential, action/karma is the kinetic. Everything is a push-pull recursive system of potential vs kinetic. Karma (kinetic energy) then later informs polarity as it creates new potential energy. Although I don't see it as a calculation, but rather an organic balancing mechanism. But that's just semantics I guess. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 12:37 PM)zedro Wrote:(04-15-2021, 12:33 PM)Patrick Wrote: It's not the intent alone. Karma requires the action, BUT the karma resulting from an action is supremely affected by the intent behind the action. I think it comes from our ability to forgive ourselves. For example, if our intent was to do harm and we do it, we may find it harder to forgive ourselves. But if you do harm without having the intent, then you may find it much easier to bring yourself to forgive yourself. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 12:44 PM)Patrick Wrote: I think it comes from our ability to forgive ourselves. For example, if our intent was to do harm and we do it, we may find it harder to forgive ourselves. But if you do harm without having the intent, then you may find it much easier to bring yourself to forgive yourself. That is one aspect/tool, but not everything requires forgiveness, unless you think it does. We are trying to meet our evolutionary potential, and karma is the expression of that motivating force. So I would say a more generalized view is 'learning', forgiveness can be nested inside that. However the paradigm for 3rd density karma appears to be more specifically centered around forgiveness/acceptance, at higher densities the focus would be different. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 12:50 PM)zedro Wrote:(04-15-2021, 12:44 PM)Patrick Wrote: I think it comes from our ability to forgive ourselves. For example, if our intent was to do harm and we do it, we may find it harder to forgive ourselves. But if you do harm without having the intent, then you may find it much easier to bring yourself to forgive yourself. I've been pondering this question quite a lot. Only from the 3d veiled perspective though. Does karma requires forgiveness? So far it seems that whatever one does to balance karma, excluding forgiveness, it never leaves it dead center. It's always balancing from one side to the other in between entities and the self. It seems that every time you succeed to completely stop the inertia is via forgiveness alone. But the process is not always called forgiveness. It may seem for example that you are meditating and pondering and that you reach a point of being able to let go (of some karma) just by doing this work, or breath work, etc. All the while it could be said that this process was you forgiving yourself and others. There are many ways of achieving this which we may not intuitively think of as forgiveness. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - flofrog - 04-15-2021 Totally think so too, Patrick RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 12:59 PM)Patrick Wrote: I've been pondering this question quite a lot. Only from the 3d veiled perspective though. Does karma requires forgiveness? You can't necessarily detect all karma, it's an invisible force that applies itself in a variable and contextual way. What you are sensing is what needs to be balanced in the immediate to progress. This is why I see it as a greater system, just not specifically as requiring forgiveness. And it doesn't need to be tracked, it's a pretty academic argument. You just need to respond to the karmic pressures as they present themselves. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 It's a chance that we are not aware of all the karma. We would probably shrivel on ourselves in hopelessness. ![]() Spoon-feeding it to us is much more workable. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 01:21 PM)Patrick Wrote: It's a chance that we are not aware of all the karma. We would probably shrivel on ourselves in hopelessness. Well it simply may not be understood, because some aspects are beyond our current level of knowing/learning/awareness. For instance Ra would have a strong karmic tie to us because of their consequential interactions in Egypt and and later LOO contact. Now they do not require to forgive themselves and accept their actions, they are beyond that, but they would have a higher level learning requirement to understand the greater impacts thereof. Now they might require that the recipients forgive them for their actions, but that is outside themselves, and invisible to the recipients conscious reality, but the higher selves would be aware. So perhaps forgiving the creation for the present circumstances may by virtue fulfill that role, but that is only a fraction of the equation. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 02:10 PM)zedro Wrote:(04-15-2021, 01:21 PM)Patrick Wrote: It's a chance that we are not aware of all the karma. We would probably shrivel on ourselves in hopelessness. I think you may be assuming that Ra acquired karma by their interactions with us in Egypt (or maybe I should say, assuming that there still is). But I cannot find anything that substantiate that. I think they remain with us out of service and love and not because there is any karma left to process. Ra 34.4 Wrote:Questioner: Thank you. Would you define karma? Everything is always subject to interpretation of course. But this from Ra has always been very loud in its meaning for me. That forgiveness and the stoppage of karma are inseparable. So on the other side of this argument where Ra still has karma with us, it could be because we humans have not released/forgiven them completely yet. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 They most definitely created karma just by interacting, that's what karma is. Again it's this negative interpretation of karma that seems to be interfering with your analysis, if you reread my descriptions above to Central Sun, you'll understand the context. Karma is not necessarily so specific, there is a much broader meaning. Its the context of 3rd density that would be specific. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 You may be right. Plus I don't believe in good karma, so that might confuse things even more in such discussions. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 I probably edited my comment after you responded....reviewing the Ra quote. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Spaced - 04-15-2021 This discussion of Karma is interesting. My personal take is that Ra's view of Karma seems to be in line with the Karma Yoga described by Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita, which states (I'm paraphrasing here but this is in Chapter 3 of the BG if anyone is interested) that one cannot attain freedom from karma by abstaining from work and renouncing the physical, indeed it is impossible to abstain from action as all beings are constantly compelled to act due to to their qualities born of material nature (represented by the three gunas which, as an aside, some tarot scholars equate with the three creatures pictured on the Wheel of Fortune card). The key to liberation then is not to renounce the physical, but to devote your action in service to others, in accordance to one's inner knowing, with no attachment to outcome. This is seen as the path of liberation from karma and the key here is the detached state. Another dimension of this is the idea of Dharma and seeing work as an act of devotion or sacrifice to the Supreme (i.e. the One Infinite Creator). To me this seems to match up with what Ra says about karma if you consider forgiveness as a way of achieving a state of acceptance and unattachment. It also seems to me to tie in to the concept of intent being related to karma. This idea of work being seen as an act of devotion also seems to line up with Ra's concept of honor/duty/responsibility. There's a passage concerning the life of Abraham Lincoln that seems to illustrate this view: Quote:35.8 Questioner: Well in that case I would like to know the motivation for this use of Abraham Lincoln’s body at that time? I believe Ra's continued involvement here is related to this concept of honor/duty/responsibility rather than karmic bonds. They are here to serve as they feel that is the best use of their service. Quote:23.10 Questioner: Thank you. Then as an overall success, what can you tell me about the relative success of the pyramid in any way at all? I understand that it was— the pyramids for the purpose were basically unsuccessful in that they didn’t produce the rise in consciousness that you’d hoped for, but there must have been some success. Can you tell me of that? The way a wanderer would become karmically involved is laid out in session 12: Quote:12.28 Questioner: Are most of these from the fourth density? What density do they come from?This seems to also point to intention being related to karma, as the wanderer must act in a consciously unloving manner. This is all just my interpretation of things, no doubt there are flaws in my understanding but I felt it to be worth sharing. I also don't wish to use quotes from the Ra material as gospel, I just find them useful in explicating my philosophical views. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 Yeah I have to admit the meaning given by Ra (and traditionally) is alot more narrow, so perhaps I'm misusing the term to go beyond the intended scope. But I feel the utilisation could be expanded to other contexts, albeit with expanded mechanisms and solutions for 'neutralizing' it. For instance, I use the term to also describe balancing principals between positive and negative interactions/interference in this plane, where if a positive entity gets to help, then a negative gets to have their turn to balance the playing field, and vice versa. Maybe I should use another term so it's more clear with the majority interpretation. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Spaced - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 04:56 PM)zedro Wrote: Yeah I have to admit the meaning given by Ra (and traditionally) is alot more narrow, so perhaps I'm misusing the term to go beyond the intended scope. But I feel the utilisation could be expanded to other contexts, albeit with expanded mechanisms and solutions for 'neutralizing' it. Yeah that is an interesting view, there is definitely a balancing mechanism at work, how that relates to karma is beyond me. I see it as related to the Justice archetype (the matrix of the body) while I see karma as related to the Wheel of Fortune (catalyst of the body). The matrix and potentiator (the Hermit) interact to produce catalyst. So maybe that could be seen as the way one directs their action (that's how I see the Hermit) coming up against the balancing mechanism to create karma. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 Yes it could be subdivided into archtypal differences, that would make sense. Ultimately tho, all the higher selves have to 'agree' that the experiences where balanced to achieve system/Logos parity. That's where I see everything finally merging. The simulation has reached is max potential based on the archtypes used and then collapses. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Sacred Fool - 04-15-2021 Returning to GCS's question at the top of the page, if those of the darker persuasion can roll merrily along up through the middle densities without hitting a karmic wall, does this mean they are very good at forgiving themselves? RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 06:29 PM)Sacred Fool Wrote: Maybe we are not forced to process karma until we decide that we want to work with it. So for STS they just accumulate the charge without ever programming anything to alleviate any of it. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 06:29 PM)Sacred Fool Wrote: Well I guess this is why the definition of karma=forgiveness feels incomplete, as it seems to be for the positive polarity in 3d, but represents a different mode for negative in 3d. Would the negative catalyser require it to be forgived? Maybe in a delayed fashion, where negative polarity choice gets to defer their karma into a higher density (early 6th?) where they are already forgiven, but need to forgive themselves at the transition point for playing that role, and would that even look like forgiveness, more like understanding? RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 I think we are allowed to delay it. But positive entities do not find any value in delaying the processing of it. Yet if only the possibility even exists for a such a thing, I can very well imagine negatives to make good use of that. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 Because at the end of the day, karma is not there to punish us, it's there as a tool for the seeker to help evolution. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 08:32 PM)Patrick Wrote: I think we are allowed to delay it. But positive entities do not find any value in delaying the processing of it. Yet if only the possibility even exists for a such a thing, I can very well imagine negatives to make good use of that. I'm thinking it has to be cleared for entry into 4d positive, at least in the context needed. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - AnthroHeart - 04-15-2021 A teacher told me the dark ones use black magic to stave off their karma. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Patrick - 04-15-2021 (04-15-2021, 08:45 PM)zedro Wrote:(04-15-2021, 08:32 PM)Patrick Wrote: I think we are allowed to delay it. But positive entities do not find any value in delaying the processing of it. Yet if only the possibility even exists for a such a thing, I can very well imagine negatives to make good use of that. Ah yes, that would make sense. Then that may explain why the Logos had to create a different 4d realm (a negative 4d) that can be experienced with your load of karma intact. RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - Ymarsakar - 04-15-2021 For real black magick, what they seem to be doing is just accelerating the bad karma. So they cannot kill people that have not done evil things. When it is their turn, they use bribes for 5th density entities to protect them when it is their turn to die. So they do not die. Like adolf. This is a very unstable oyramid acheme RE: What does "The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions" mean? - zedro - 04-15-2021 It would make sense why the negative 95% polarity threshold is so high, only then do you get to delay the karma, but less than that means a tough ride as you don't get the exemption because you aren't migrating to 4d- |